fix: clear price to null when a comparison finds no merchant offer
Build & Deploy / build (push) Failing after 3s
Build & Deploy / docker (push) Skipped

Several memory sticks (e.g. Crucial CT8G48C40U5, Patriot Signature Line,
Kingston FURY Beast) kept displaying their pc-builder.io catalog price
("€35.99", "€39.99"...) even after clicking "Compare prices" and getting
"No live price found, using catalog price" - an unconfirmed number was
being shown as if it were still valid, which is misleading given
pc-builder.io's catalog is known to go stale (see the earlier RTX 5070
€128 vs €66.89 case).

New clearPriceIfNoOffers(): when ScrapedPartsController#compare finds
zero offers across all 7 supported merchants, the part's price/priceSource
are reset to null, regardless of whether the price previously came from
the pc-builder.io catalog or an earlier verified merchant match - per
explicit product decision, an empty comparison always wins over keeping a
possibly-stale number around.

- ScrapedPartsController#compare now calls clearPriceIfNoOffers() in the
  empty-offers branch, and returns the resulting price in the JSON
  response so the frontend can mirror it exactly
- NewPartSearch.vue: comparePrices() now sets part.price from the
  response's `price` field (mirroring exactly what the backend just
  persisted) instead of only updating it on a cheaper find; removed the
  now-inaccurate "using catalog price €X" message since that price no
  longer exists once compared with no result
- 3 new tests for clearPriceIfNoOffers: clears an unverified
  pc-builder.io price, also clears a previously-verified merchant price
  when no longer confirmed, and is a no-op when there was no price to
  begin with

Verified end-to-end against the reported Crucial CT8G48C40U5 example:
price went from 35.99 (pc-builder.io) to null after a real comparison
found zero matching offers on any merchant.
This commit is contained in:
Kevin L'Hereec committed 2026-07-24 11:20:47 +02:00
1 parent fa74791c92
commit 0ce6a7f4a7
4 files changed
+96 -19

No files matched your search

+13 -2
View File
@@ -2,7 +2,11 @@ import type { HttpContext } from '@adonisjs/core/http'
import vine from '@vinejs/vine'
import ScrapedPart from '#models/scraped_part'
import ComponentType from '#models/component_type'
import { ensureFreshCategory, updatePriceIfCheaper } from '#services/part_scraper_service'
import {
ensureFreshCategory,
updatePriceIfCheaper,
clearPriceIfNoOffers,
} from '#services/part_scraper_service'
import { findCheapestOffers } from '#services/merchant_price_service'
const SEARCH_RESULTS_LIMIT = 150
@@ -76,6 +80,11 @@ export default class ScrapedPartsController {
* (or no price was known yet), it's persisted as the new default price
* (see updatePriceIfCheaper) — so this comparison benefits every future
* search/import for this part, not just the current user.
*
* If NO merchant confirms a price at all, the part's price is cleared
* to null (see clearPriceIfNoOffers) rather than silently keeping a
* pc-builder.io catalog price the user just explicitly asked to verify
* and that no longer checks out anywhere.
*/
async compare({ request, auth, response }: HttpContext) {
await auth.authenticate()
@@ -91,8 +100,10 @@ export default class ScrapedPartsController {
if (offers.length > 0) {
await updatePriceIfCheaper(part, offers[0])
} else {
await clearPriceIfNoOffers(part)
}
return response.json({ offers })
return response.json({ offers, price: part.price })
}
}
+22
View File
@@ -415,12 +415,34 @@ async function updatePriceIfCheaper(
await part.save()
}
/**
* Clears a part's price when a live comparison found no matching offer on
* any supported merchant (see ScrapedPartsController#compare), regardless
* of where the price previously came from (pc-builder.io catalog or an
* earlier verified merchant match). The pc-builder.io catalog price this
* part started with is frequently stale (see shouldKeepExistingPrice's
* doc for a confirmed example: pc-builder.io showed €128 for a CPU
* actually selling for €66.89) — once a user explicitly asks to verify a
* price and no merchant confirms it anymore, keeping the old number
* around is misleading, so it's dropped to null instead of silently
* falling back to "using catalog price €X".
*/
async function clearPriceIfNoOffers(part: ScrapedPart): Promise<void> {
if (part.price === null) return
part.price = null
part.priceSource = null
part.priceCheckedAt = DateTime.now()
await part.save()
}
export {
scrapeAllCategories,
scrapeComponentType,
ensureFreshCategory,
isCategoryStale,
updatePriceIfCheaper,
clearPriceIfNoOffers,
shouldKeepExistingPrice,
CATEGORY_CONFIG,
CATEGORY_SLUGS,
+13 -17
View File
@@ -62,21 +62,20 @@ async function comparePrices(part: ScrapedPart) {
}
const data = await response.json()
offers[part.id] = data.offers ?? []
// The backend already persists this exact value server-side (see
// ScrapedPartsController#compare): the cheapest offer's price when
// one was found (updatePriceIfCheaper), or null when no merchant
// confirmed a price at all (clearPriceIfNoOffers) — an unverified
// pc-builder.io catalog price is not kept around just because the
// comparison came back empty. Mirror that here on the locally held
// result so the display (e.g. "€979.95" or "No price yet") reflects
// it immediately, instead of the initial search-result price sticking
// around until the user re-runs the search from scratch.
part.price = data.price ?? null
if (offers[part.id].length === 0) {
compareErrors[part.id] = true
return
}
// The backend already persists the cheapest offer found as this
// part's new best-known price when it beats the catalog price (see
// ScrapedPartsController#compare / updatePriceIfCheaper). Mirror that
// here on the locally held result so the displayed catalog price
// (e.g. "€979.95") reflects it immediately, instead of staying stuck
// at whatever price the initial search returned until the user
// re-runs the search from scratch.
const cheapest = offers[part.id][0]
if (part.price === null || cheapest.price < part.price) {
part.price = cheapest.price
}
} catch {
compareErrors[part.id] = true
@@ -185,10 +184,7 @@ function importPart(part: ScrapedPart) {
</a>
</template>
<span v-if="compareErrors[part.id] && part.price !== null" class="text-xs text-gray-400">
No live price found, using catalog price €{{ part.price.toFixed(2) }}
</span>
<span v-else-if="compareErrors[part.id]" class="text-xs text-gray-400">
<span v-if="compareErrors[part.id]" class="text-xs text-gray-400">
No price found on any merchant for this part.
</span>
</div>
+48
View File
@@ -7,6 +7,7 @@ import {
isCategoryStale,
ensureFreshCategory,
updatePriceIfCheaper,
clearPriceIfNoOffers,
shouldKeepExistingPrice,
CACHE_TTL_HOURS,
} from '#services/part_scraper_service'
@@ -217,6 +218,53 @@ test.group('Best-known-price persistence', () => {
})
})
test.group('clearPriceIfNoOffers', () => {
test('clears an unverified pc-builder.io catalog price when no merchant confirms it', async ({
assert,
}) => {
// Regression: memory sticks kept showing pc-builder.io catalog prices
// (e.g. €35.99) even though comparing prices found no matching offer
// on any merchant ("No live price found, using catalog price €35.99")
// — an unconfirmed number should not be displayed as if it were still
// valid.
const type = await createType('Memory-clear-1')
const part = await createScrapedPart(type.id, 'ZZZ-Test-Clear-A', 'clear-a-p1', 35.99)
await clearPriceIfNoOffers(part)
await part.refresh()
assert.isNull(part.price)
assert.isNull(part.priceSource)
})
test('also clears a price previously verified by a merchant if no longer confirmed', async ({
assert,
}) => {
const type = await createType('Memory-clear-2')
const part = await createScrapedPart(type.id, 'ZZZ-Test-Clear-B', 'clear-b-p1', 50)
part.priceSource = 'LDLC'
await part.save()
await clearPriceIfNoOffers(part)
await part.refresh()
assert.isNull(part.price)
assert.isNull(part.priceSource)
})
test('is a no-op when the part already has no price', async ({ assert }) => {
const type = await createType('Memory-clear-3')
const part = await createScrapedPart(type.id, 'ZZZ-Test-Clear-C', 'clear-c-p1', null)
const originalCheckedAt = part.priceCheckedAt
await clearPriceIfNoOffers(part)
await part.refresh()
assert.isNull(part.price)
assert.equal(part.priceCheckedAt, originalCheckedAt)
})
})
test.group('Catalog refresh price protection (shouldKeepExistingPrice)', () => {
test('an unverified pc-builder.io price is NOT protected and gets overwritten', ({ assert }) => {
// Regression test: a GPU had price=431.17 from a previous pc-builder.io